By the last afternoon, long stretches of shelving at the Lyons Mall Stop & Shop were empty, and most of the inventory had already been sold. The store at 553 South Finley Avenue closed for good at 6 p.m. on Thursday, Oct. 29. The next morning the sign was gone from the building, as New Jersey Hills reported.
Thanksgiving falls on Thursday, Nov. 26. For the first time in 55 years, Bernards Township will host it without a supermarket. The holiday used to depend on one store that stayed open through the final rush. This year it depends on a set of dates, and the most important ones fall in the coming week, well before anyone starts brining a turkey.
Fifty-Five Years Under One Roof
The Lyons Mall space has fed the township longer than most residents have lived here. Grand Union was the mall's first tenant and opened with a ribbon-cutting on Aug. 25, 1970. Grand Union Co. of Wayne later filed for bankruptcy, and in January 2001 the store passed to Stop & Shop through a liquidation sale. The doors never closed during the handoff. The space is about 30,000 square feet.
The township once had more than one store. An A&P opened in the Dewy Meadow Village complex off King George Road in June 2002 and closed in November 2015, after the national chain filed for bankruptcy. That building was torn down in May 2019 to make room for apartments. Just over the border, the Kings in Bernardsville Centre on Route 202 opened as an Acme in July 1956 and closed in January 2021. Each closing pushed more of the township's grocery shopping to South Finley Avenue. By this fall, according to New Jersey Hills, the Stop & Shop was the township's only supermarket, and the Bernardsville ShopRite on Route 202 was its only competitor within several miles.
Stop & Shop spokesman Daniel Wolk told Patch in July that the company made the decision "after a routine evaluation of our store operations" and that all associates would be offered transfers to other locations. The company's Westfield store on Elm Street was the other New Jersey location to close this fall.
The Space Is Meant for Food Again
Lyons Mall owner Barbara Mackes told New Jersey Hills in late July that an announcement would be coming. In October, Mayor Ana Duarte McCarthy contacted the mall owner. She was told the space would be filled by a food retailer, which could not be named while the lease was still being negotiated.
"We hope that indeed comes to be," the mayor said of the prospect, in the New Jersey Hills account of the closing.
Earlier, in July, the mayor said the incoming tenant was preparing plans and specifications for township review, as Patch reported. A food retailer in that space would put a full grocery list back on South Finley Avenue. Whenever it opens, it will be after this holiday. So this Thanksgiving's menu comes from smaller stores on a tighter schedule.
The Calendar That Replaces the Wednesday-Night Run
The supermarket's main advantage at Thanksgiving was that it stayed open late. The sources that replace it close earlier, and most of the deadlines below land before the holiday week:
- Saturday, Nov. 14, 9 a.m. to 1 p.m. The next-to-last regular Saturday at the Bernardsville Farmers' Market, which has been bringing local farmers, bakers and makers together for more than 30 years.
- Monday, Nov. 16. The final day to pre-order a Thanksgiving turkey, sides and desserts at Green's Natural Foods. Orders are placed in person on a form at the store.
- Saturday, Nov. 21, 9 a.m. to 1 p.m. The Bernardsville Farmers' Market's last listed Saturday of the season, five days before the holiday.
- Thursday through Sunday, each week. The farm store at English Farm, 3625 Valley Road in Liberty Corner, is open Thursday and Friday from noon to 4 p.m. and Saturday and Sunday from 11 a.m. to 4 p.m. It offers certified-organic vegetables year-round.
- Thursday, Nov. 26. Thanksgiving.
For anyone counting on a prepared turkey from inside the township, the order goes in on Monday, a full ten days before the meal.
What Each In-Town Stop Covers
Green's Natural Foods, 25 Mountainview Blvd. Green's is now the township's remaining grocery store, which Patch pointed out when the closing was announced. The Basking Ridge store is one of the Green's locations taking holiday pre-orders. The order form covers a fresh Koch's natural or organic turkey along with prepared sides and pies. The prepared foods are made with all-natural ingredients and include gluten-free and vegan options. The holiday guide lists turkey stuffing and vegan stuffing, turkey gravy and vegan gravy, potatoes, sweet potato mash, green beans, carrots and a cranberry-almond quinoa. Pies come in classic pumpkin, classic apple and sweet potato. The shelves also carry everyday staples such as eggnog, cranberry sauce, pumpkin puree and pie shells.
M&M Perrotti's Butcher Shop, 77 South Maple Ave. Perrotti's butcher counter carries prime beef, pork and fresh Bell & Evans chicken. Its catering catalog includes prepared sides such as mashed potatoes and sweet potatoes. In past seasons the shop has sold fresh Jaindl turkeys by phone order. For this year's holiday terms, call the counter.
The Baker, 96 South Finley Ave. The Baker makes organic sourdough breads, croissants, scones and pretzels, and its site has a Thanksgiving pre-order page. The coffee there comes from Barrister Coffee House, which now roasts for wholesale and retail only and also supplies Washington House, M&M Perrotti's and SoBol, according to New Jersey Hills. A bag of beans for the morning after is just as easy to pick up.
Washington House, 55 South Finley Ave. The restaurant takes online pickup orders and caters private events. That makes it the downtown call for anyone hosting a gathering in the days around the holiday rather than the meal itself.
The South Finley Avenue delis round out the block. Copper Kettle Deli is at 118 South Finley and Mariana's Deli at 35 South Finley, a few doors from the old Stop & Shop's Lyons Mall address. In its spring coverage of downtown, New Jersey Hills described parking along South Finley between Oak and Henry streets as tight. That stretch matters more when several stops on a holiday list share one block.
When the List Still Needs a Full Supermarket
Paper towels, a second bag of ice and the forgotten can of chicken stock still call for a full-size store. When the closing was announced, New Jersey Hills named the three other supermarkets in the five Somerset Hills towns:
| Store | Road | Town |
|---|---|---|
| ShopRite | Route 202 | Bernardsville |
| Kings | Route 206 | Bedminster |
| The Fresh Market | Washington Valley Road | Pluckemin |
Each is outside the township, and that is the real change this season. A last-minute run on Wednesday, Nov. 25 now means a drive to another town instead of a stop on South Finley Avenue. The in-town alternative is to place the Green's order by Monday and get to the farm stand over the weekend.
Once the holiday passes, downtown's next big date is the township's Winter Market and Christmas Tree Lighting on Saturday, Dec. 5, from noon to 7 p.m., organized by the Basking Ridge Business Alliance.
At Karen Canniffe, we watch changes like the Lyons Mall vacancy closely, because a town's errands are part of how its homes are judged. If you're thinking about a sale in Basking Ridge and want to know how this season's changes fit into your home's story, request a complimentary home valuation and we'll walk you through it.