Which of New Providence's New Homes Are for Sale

This fall, demolition crews went to work on an office building at 121 Chanlon Road in Murray Hill. It was the former Martindale-Hubbell headquarters, a short walk from the Murray Hill train station. According to the New Providence Planning Board's September 22, 2026 minutes, demolition was still underway that night, a pre-construction meeting was set for October 1, and Toll Brothers was to take possession of the property once demolition was complete.

Toll is building townhomes there. Within the borough's current wave of construction, Chanlon Road is the one project with homes priced for an outside buyer to purchase. The rest are rentals. The Chanlon Road prices sit in the same range where New Providence's resale market had almost no houses listed this fall. If you are comparing New Providence with Summit, Berkeley Heights or Westfield, this new construction is coming late, in small numbers, and at a specific price point.

Three Projects, and Who Each One Is For

Here is what is built, approved or under way in New Providence as of this week, with whether each one is for sale or for rent.

Project Location Homes Rent or sale Where it stands
Providence Place, Garden Communities 111 Spring Street 192 apartments plus townhomes Rent Apartments delivered spring 2026
70 Ryder Way, NP Mountain Developers, LLC Ryder Way 297 age-restricted units: 257 apartments, 40 townhomes Rent Approved January 13, 2026
Toll Brothers townhomes 121 Chanlon Road 83 townhomes in the December 2025 revised plan Sale Resolution approved April 7, 2026; site demolition this fall

Count the homes a household can buy on the open market and you get the 62 market-rate townhomes in Toll's revised plan. Providence Place and 70 Ryder Way add 489 apartments and age-restricted units between them, plus Providence Place's townhomes, all for rent. On April 7, 2026, the Planning Board voted 6–0, with no one opposed, to approve the resolution for the Toll application, Application #2024-04. The same April 7 meeting also approved the Ryder Way resolution.

The Chanlon Road Townhomes Are Priced Like Houses

TAPinto New Providence reported that Toll returned to the Planning Board in December 2025 with a revised plan of 83 townhomes: 62 market-rate and 21 affordable. Market-rate units were projected at $1.2 million to $1.3 million. The same TAPinto report describes three-story homes. The first floor has a garage and a recreation room, the second has the kitchen, great room and a covered terrace, and the bedrooms are on the third. The plan has 12 buildings with pitched roofs and front doors beside the garages, and 200 to 205 parking spaces, more than the 166 the borough requires. That projection dates from December 2025. Treat it as the developer's estimate from that hearing, not a price list.

Compare that projection with the county figures. The New Jersey REALTORS Union County report for October 2026, current as of November 9, puts the October median townhouse-condo sale at $508,000 and the October median single-family sale at $680,000. At its projected price, a market-rate Chanlon Road townhome would cost well over twice the county's median October townhouse-condo sale and nearly twice its median single-family sale.

So a Chanlon Road townhome is not competing with the county's condos. Its competition is the four- and five-bedroom resale house in New Providence. A buyer at $1.25 million is choosing between two things. One is a new three-story townhome, a short walk from the Murray Hill station, with a garage and no yard work. The other is an older single-family house on its own lot somewhere else in the borough. That choice matters more to this buyer than whether condos are cheap.

This Fall, That Price Range Was Nearly Empty

A mid-October MLS snapshot showed seven active listings in New Providence. Two were townhomes and five were single-family houses. Seventeen homes were under contract. The eight sales closed in the previous 30 days averaged just under $1.5 million, sold for about 2 percent over asking, and took an average of 16 days on market. The active list prices that week jumped from about $839,000 to $1.895 million, with almost nothing in the $1 million to $1.5 million range, where demand for four- and five-bedroom homes in town is concentrated.

Put those numbers next to the Toll projection. The new townhomes are projected at $1.2 million to $1.3 million, which falls in exactly the range where New Providence had almost no resale inventory this fall. Seventeen homes under contract against seven for sale is a market where a well-priced house goes in two to three weeks.

The county is looser than the borough. In Union County, single-family inventory in October 2026 was 689 homes, up 18.4 percent from a year earlier, or 2.9 months of supply. Sellers received 102.7 percent of list price that month, down from 104.3 percent in October 2025. Through October, the county's year-to-date single-family median was $700,000, and sellers received 104.8 percent of list. More homes are for sale across Union County, and buyers have a bit more room to negotiate than they did a year ago. New Providence's mid-October count does not show the same easing at its price point.

The Rentals Give Relocating Buyers Somewhere to Live While They Search

None of the rental homes adds a listing for a buyer, but they do change the options for a family moving here on a deadline. Providence Place sits on 27 acres half a mile from the Murray Hill station. It has 192 apartments with covered parking plus two- and three-bedroom townhomes with private driveways and garages. Apartments run up to 1,845 square feet and townhomes up to 2,412. TAPinto reported in June 2026 that the apartments were 50 percent leased less than three months after delivery, that the townhomes were 95 percent occupied, and that monthly rents started at $4,245.

For a relocating family, that is a practical option. They can sign a lease near the station, then wait for the right house in a market where good listings go under contract in about two weeks. When houses are scarce, it often pays to wait inside the town rather than search from outside it.

At 70 Ryder Way, the April 7, 2026 resolution describes two multifamily buildings and eight townhome buildings, with a pool and two pickleball courts. According to TAPinto, the project is age-restricted rental housing with 59 affordable apartments. For a buyer looking for a single-family house, it does not add inventory. It may matter more to a longtime owner who is thinking about selling and wants to stay in New Providence without owning a house.

Questions Buyers Ask About New Providence's New Construction

What kind of homes is Toll building on Chanlon Road?

The revised plan Toll presented in December 2025 calls for three-story townhomes with garages on the ground floor, in 12 buildings on the former office site.

How close is it to the train?

The site is near NJ Transit's Murray Hill station, the same station Providence Place is half a mile from. For a buyer, the station is the main thing the townhomes have that most resale houses in town at the same price do not.

Should I wait for Chanlon Road or buy a resale house now?

That depends on your timeline. As of late September, the site was still being demolished and Toll had not yet taken possession. A household that has to move in 2027 is shopping the resale market as it stands, which in mid-October had five single-family houses for sale.

Will the new construction affect values for existing owners?

The for-sale piece is small. Sixty-two market-rate townhomes, in a town that had seventeen homes under contract at once in mid-October, add supply gradually, not all at once. If the townhomes sell at the projected $1.2 million to $1.3 million, they also give appraisers new sales to compare against at that price.

If you own a four- or five-bedroom home in New Providence and are weighing a 2027 sale, the timing question is concrete. You want to list while the $1 million to $1.5 million range is still this thin, and before the Chanlon Road townhomes come to market at that price. Karen Canniffe can show you where your house fits against both. Request a complimentary home valuation, or see more on the New Providence neighborhood page.

Work With Karen

My clients appreciate the time, care, expertise, guidance and perseverance I provide to them throughout the entire home buying and selling process.

Let's Connect