Why Short Hills Sale Prices Keep Stopping Just Short of the Line

On September 1, a 1931 house at 35 Woodland Road in Short Hills sold for $1,999,999, just one dollar under $2 million.

That one-dollar gap explains a lot of what Short Hills sale prices look like in 2026. The state's fee schedule has four lines that fall right where much of this market trades. This summer and fall, recorded sales stacked up just below those lines and stayed out of the zones just above them.

A Rate That Applies to the Whole Price

The graduated fee comes on top of New Jersey's regular Realty Transfer Fee. It applies to residential sales over $1,000,000. The rate is 1% when the price is over $1 million up to $2 million, 2% over $2 million up to $2.5 million, 2.5% over $2.5 million up to $3 million, 3% over $3 million up to $3.5 million, and 3.5% above $3.5 million. That schedule is listed on the NJ Division of Taxation's realty transfer fee page.

The key detail is that each rate applies to the entire price, not just the dollars above the line. The Division's July 2025 notice gives an example: a $2.75 million sale owes 2.5% of $2.75 million, or $68,750, at recording.

Who pays also changed. Before July 10, 2025, the buyer paid a flat 1% on sales over $1 million. Under P.L. 2025, c. 69, the fee became graduated and moved to the seller. The Division says that for deeds submitted on or after July 10, the law makes the seller legally responsible for all transfer fees.

Because the fee is a flat percentage of the whole price, each threshold creates a cliff. The law firm Morgan Lewis described the ranges just above the thresholds as "dead zones" shortly after the change took effect.

These numbers use the state's published rates and count the graduated fee only, not the regular transfer fee:

Threshold Fee at the line Fee one dollar over
$2,000,000 $20,000 about $40,000
$2,500,000 $50,000 about $62,500
$3,000,000 $75,000 about $90,000
$3,500,000 $105,000 about $122,500

Where Short Hills Sales Landed This Summer and Fall

NJ.com publishes a weekly list of the ten most expensive home sales recorded in Essex County. From July through mid-October 2026, Short Hills and Millburn homes appeared on those lists again and again. Their prices group around the thresholds.

At or just under $2 million:

  • 35 Woodland Road, Short Hills: $1,999,999, completed September 1
  • 62 Southern Slope Drive, Millburn: $1,999,999, completed July 29
  • 28 Kilmer Drive, Short Hills: $1,999,000, completed September 4
  • 24 Canoe Brook Road, Short Hills: $1,999,000, completed September 17
  • 272 Glen Ave. and 84 Cedar Street, Millburn: $2,000,000 each, completed July 1 and June 30

The same pattern shows up at the higher lines. 1 Lenape Road sold for $2,450,000 in June. 28 Coleridge Road sold for $2,445,000. 14 Denman Court sold for $2,450,000 in September. Near $3 million, 58 Merrywood Lane sold for $2,995,000, 55 Lakeview Ave. for $2,999,000, 19 Hilltop Road for $2,975,000, and 2 Denman Court for $2,950,000. 3 Denman Court recorded at exactly $3,000,000. At the top line, 126 Fairfield Drive and 8 Roland Drive each sold for $3,500,000, and 123 Highland Ave. sold for $3,450,000.

The gaps above the lines are as clear as the clusters below them. The closest Short Hills sales above $2 million were 9 Overlook Terrace at $2,100,000 and 24 Rippling Brook Drive at $2,108,108. Above $2.5 million, the closest was 85 Athens Road at $2,625,000. Above $3 million, it was 11 Cayuga Way at $3,155,000. Above $3.5 million, it was 96 Westview Road at $3,740,000. No sale on these lists landed inside a dead zone.

These lists show each week's ten priciest recordings countywide, not every sale. Prices ending in 999 were common long before the fee changed. The clustering fits the fee schedule closely, but these lists alone do not prove the fee caused it.

Why the Lines Sit in the Middle of This Market

Across Essex County, the thresholds are far from a typical sale. In September 2026, the county's median single-family sale price was $750,000. Homes sold for 106.3% of list price on average, took a median of 32 days to sell, and the market had 2.8 months of supply, according to the NJ REALTORS monthly report for Essex County. At that median, most county sales never reach the graduated fee.

Short Hills is different. Its recorded sales on the summer and fall lists run from just under $2 million to $5.2 million. That puts all four cliffs inside the range where homes in this town routinely trade. In a town where homes sell above list price, a seller fielding offers near $2 million faces a choice most Essex County sellers never see.

The same lines show up in nearby towns with similar prices. In Union County, 28 Club Lane in Summit recorded at $2,000,000 in July. In Westfield, 734 Woodland Ave. and 935 Minisink Way both recorded at $1,999,999. 170 Killarney Drive in Berkeley Heights sold for $1,999,000. 244 Highland Ave. in Montclair sold for $1,999,999. Short Hills just meets the lines more often, because more of its sales happen near them.

What the Lines Do to Price as a Signal

Three Short Hills homes sold at $1,999,000 or $1,999,999 in September. 35 Woodland Road had 2,217 square feet, 28 Kilmer Drive had 2,584, and 24 Canoe Brook Road had 2,941. Size is only one measure of value. Still, almost identical prices covered a 700-square-foot difference.

Nearby sales at the line are not necessarily equal homes.

The fee schedule, who pays it, and how a contract might split the cost are legal and tax questions. This post is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice, so please confirm your own situation with a real estate attorney or tax professional.

Questions Short Hills Buyers and Sellers Ask

Does the higher rate apply only to the amount over the threshold? No. The Division of Taxation applies the rate to the total price, as its $2.75 million example shows.

Is the regular Realty Transfer Fee still charged? Yes. The graduated fee is in addition to it, and the seller is responsible for both, according to the Division's fee page.

Is the fee likely to change? Senate Bill S964 would eliminate the fee and two other transfer fees. It was introduced and referred to the Senate Community and Urban Affairs Committee on January 13, 2026, according to the Legislature's bill page. It has not been enacted. NJ Spotlight News reported in September that the graduated fee had brought in nearly $70 million since the current fiscal year began.

Karen Canniffe can show you how recent Short Hills sales compare. Request a complimentary home valuation to get started.

Work With Karen

My clients appreciate the time, care, expertise, guidance and perseverance I provide to them throughout the entire home buying and selling process.

Let's Connect